Abstract
Restoration of demised keystone-species populations is an overriding concern in conservation biology. However, since no population is independent of its environment, progress is needed in predicting the efficacy of restoration in unstable ecological contexts. Here, by means of Population Dynamics P-system Models (PDP), we studied long-term changes in the population size of Egyptian vultures (Neophron percnopterus) inhabiting a Natural Park, northern Spain, to changes in the numbers of wild rabbits (Oryctolagus cuniculus), a keystone-species of Mediterranean ecosystems that have suffered >90% population decline after a hemorrhagic disease outbreak. Low availability of rabbit carcasses leads Egyptian vultures to extend their foraging activities to unprotected areas with higher non-natural mortality whereas growing numbers of griffon vultures (Gyps fulvus), a dominant competitor, progressively monopolize trophic resources resulting in a focal population decrease. Modeling shows that, even if keystone-species populations recover in core protected areas, the return to the original studied population size may be unfeasible, due to both the high non-natural mortality rates in humanized areas and long-term changes in the scavenger guild structure. Policy decisions aimed to restore keystone-species should rely on holistic approaches integrating the effects of spatial heterogeneity on both producer and consumer populations as well as within-guild processes.
Similar content being viewed by others
Introduction
The keystone species concept in ecology has a long history1,2, acknowledging the disproportionate impact that the abundances of certain populations of definite organisms may have on ecosystems. Some aspects of the application of this concept to the practice of conservation have been greatly discussed, in particular, how to narrow the definition of keystone species to avoid losing its value1,2. It is beyond doubt, however, that the rarefaction or disappearance of some taxa at any trophic level, from large predators or detritivores to pollinators, encompasses profound implications for population viability of other species and overall for the structure and functioning of food webs, communities and ecosystems (see3,4). The restoration of the populations of these species, or closely related taxa that could fulfill similar functions, is therefore an emerging research field both in ecology and conservation sciences5,6 and is considered a priority for policy managers (see7 and references therein).
The European wild rabbit (Oryctolagus cuniculus) is considered a keystone species in the Mediterranean within food webs (see review in8). It is the main prey for at least 29 predators (17 raptors and 9 carnivores9), some of which are endemic rabbit-specialists in the Western Mediterranean region (e.g. the Spanish Imperial Eagle (Aquila adalberti) and the Iberian lynx (Lynx pardinus)10). The sudden appearance of Rabbit Hemorrhagic Disease (RHD) during the 1990s caused a sharp decline in their populations, with rabbits disappearing from much of their former areas of distribution11,12. Consequently, numeric and functional responses of consumers were triggered. Both rabbit-specialists and mesopredator species shifted their distribution areas and altered their breeding and population dynamics, which are also shaped by an increase in intra- and interspecific competition for this scarcer trophic resource13,14,15,16,17. On a shorter time-scale, the wild rabbit rarefaction in wilder and protected Mediterranean ecosystems forced rabbit-consumers to forage in open humanized areas often associated with agricultural practices, where the risk of non-natural mortality is higher18. Additionally, the vanishing of wild rabbits, considered an important game species, led to the increase in direct and indirect persecution of predators, often through illegal methods such as poisoning19,20.
The magnitude of the problem is so serious that to counteract the negative trends in the wild rabbit populations and consequently the declining endangered consumer species, costly conservation programs in many Mediterranean regions, often at a considerable cost, have been carried out. For example, in Spain, the European LIFE–Nature projects devoted to recovering rabbit–specialist predators (which take specific actions focused on increasing populations of lagomorphs) have invested more than 94 million Euros in these efforts21,22,23. Meanwhile, important quantities of public funds are also devoted to reduce direct and indirect human–induced mortality of predators and scavengers24. However, from an ecological point of view, these initiatives have neglected the possibility that the return to original scenarios could be detrimental, especially in Europe. Here, more intensive agriculture, resulting in major landscape transformations, forces large body-sized vertebrates to inhabit increasingly hostile environments25. In addition, these changes may distort the interspecific relationships within food webs26. In this context, it seems desirable to examine whether the recovery of wild rabbit populations would lead to increases in consumer population, similar to those seen previous to the RHD outbreak.
Here we use an empirical-bioinspired modeling approach to examine this issue using as a case study a binomial-system: the wild rabbit (Oryctolagus cuniculus) and the threatened Egyptian vulture (Neophron percnopterus). We took advantage of long-term and high-quality data collected in a Natural Park in northern Spain. There, the demise of the lagomorph population due to RHD led breeding Egyptian vultures to modify their foraging habits and look for alternative food sources (mainly livestock carcasses) in humanized areas outside the limits of the protected area where the probability of non-natural mortality increased27. Moreover, the scavenger guild composition has greatly varied in this region over the last few decades of the study period; the Eurasian griffon vultures (Gyps fulvus) are progressively outnumbering the short-bodied and less-competitive scavengers28,29. In this context, wild rabbit carcasses, previously exploited almost exclusively by Egyptian vultures, are increasingly consumed by griffons (see30, see below for details).
Here, our specific goals were to: i) determine the long-term viability of the population of the focal species; and to examine how Egyptian vulture population dynamics would evolve given changes in ii) wild rabbit abundance; iii) non-natural mortality in humanized areas; and iv) long-term population-trends of direct competitors (griffon vultures). To examine these issues we used Population Dynamics P-system Models (PDP)31. These models belong to the family of models developed by32 and were initially created to simulate the functioning of organelles in the cell (i.e., varying their numbers and operating parallel in a synchronous and interrelated manner). There is a close parallelism between the functioning of cells and ecosystems making P-systems an increasingly useful tool in many different research lines including animal behavior, invasion processes and conservation planning33,34,35,36.
Results
The projections of our model closely reproduced the observed Egyptian vulture population trend in the study area over the last three decades; in fact, the empirical data were within the 95% confidence intervals (Fig. 1). The immature fraction of the population, after a slight increase, would have decreased by almost half in the same period. Interestingly, the projections about the future trends showed that maintaining the current demographic parameters, conditions of food availability and the trophic interspecific competition with griffon vultures, the Egyptian vulture breeding population would undergo a slight increase of about 25% (from 40 to 50 adults). The number of immature birds would also increase by about 30% (Fig. 2).
Our model also estimated that the biomass of wild rabbit carcasses consumed by the Egyptian vultures since the early 1990s has continuously decreased, stabilizing in recent years. On the other hand, the number of wild rabbit carcasses consumed by griffon vultures would have gradually increased to stabilization (Fig. 3). The modeling shows that in 2013, Egyptian and griffon vultures would have consumed 73% and 27% of the available wild rabbit carcasses, respectively. Simulations of future scenarios showed that a twofold increase in the griffon vulture population in the area would occur within 35 years and most of the griffons would consume as many rabbit carcasses as Egyptian vultures. Consequently, the models suggested a long-term population decline of Egyptian vultures (Fig. 2).
Finally, we estimated the sensitivity of the parameters (i.e., the effects of a change of 1% in their values) related to food availability, mortality by poisoning or natural mortality in a time horizon of 35 years. We found very little sensitivity to uncertainty in model projections: 0.43 more females after an increase of 1% in food availability or −1.17 and −2.04 females, after an increase of 1% in mortality due to poisoning and natural mortality, respectively.
Analysis using Box-Behnken procedures based on different conservation policies and management scenarios combining variations in both food availability and human-induced mortality showed that the numbers of Egyptian vultures are extremely sensitive to the latter factor (Fig. 4). Under current parameters any decrease in survival rates may lead unequivocally to population decline. Even with similar mortality rates, the models show positive population trends only if the wild rabbit populations recover by more than 40%. These projections also revealed much more positive results for non-breeding birds due to their lower sensitivity to mortality. Finally, modeling showed that if the griffon vulture populations double their population size, the recovery of the Egyptian vulture population (especially the breeding fraction) would be jeopardized even in scenarios where management actions focuses exclusively on eliminating the causes of non-natural mortality.
Discussion
Our results show that even if the populations of wild rabbit recover, non-natural mortality of Egyptian vultures associated with the alternative exploitation of humanized landscapes would heavily condition the future viability of its population. Moreover, the modeling procedures show that the long-term changes in the composition of the scavenger guild may also play a determinant role: if the population of the dominant griffon vulture continues to increase, it would consume a significant part of the trophic resources (wild rabbit carcasses) to the detriment of the more threatened and less competitive scavenger.
Our modeling was fully parameterized from the beginning and faithfully reproduced the empirically observed long-term population trends despite the inherent simplicity of the model. This is probably a consequence of the data quality introduced into the model, which was obtained during a long-term study and allowed the true reproducibility of the process. In addition, the predictions were only very weakly sensitive to uncertainty in the parameters. However, some potentially important parameters that were not included may have additive effects that would merit consideration in future studies. This is true of the likely spatial asymmetries in the density of wild rabbits and the differential exploitation of land by Egyptian vultures living in territories of variable quality. In this regard, in some large body-sized birds of prey, home ranges varied with prey density and individual reproductive status, with habitat quality serving as a regulatory mechanism of space use (see e.g.37,38). In addition, it seems reasonable that the consumption of rabbit carcasses by vultures represents less than what our model assumes. This may be true because, apart from our focal species, there are other facultative avian scavengers and carnivores exploiting the same trophic resource39. Moreover, our studied population is not independent from those existing in the neighboring regions (upper Ebro Valley and Pyrenees) and may receive immigrants, which have certainly helped to slow population decline27 (unpublished data).
According to our findings, the priority conservation strategy is to focus on the recovery of wild rabbit populations. This goal, however, is difficult to achieve. Although rabbit populations have strongly recovered in certain areas over the last few decades, this recovery follows a very irregular spatial pattern probably due to the local environmental variability in shaping factors like vegetation cover, the presence and abundance of disease vectors, predation and hunting pressure, whose relative contribution is still poorly understood (see8 and references therein). In fact, in our study area rabbit population recovery has been negligible as has been the case in other Iberian Mediterranean ecosystems8,40. Additionally, in 2012-2013 a new viral disease reached the Iberian Peninsula posing an additive risk of mortality to wild rabbit populations41,42. Thus, at least in the short to medium term, a significant increase in wild rabbit populations in this area is unlikely. In other Mediterranean regions, the scenario would be different and vegetation succession and reforestation after land abandonment may be the rule43,44. These conditions are predicted to favor large scavengers due to the increase/expansion of wild ungulate populations45,46 but they may be less favorable for rabbit existence due to the well-known affinity of the lagomorph to open habitats47. Consequently, the Egyptian vulture, as well as other facultative scavengers linked to open and diverse Mediterranean landscapes, would be negatively affected by these processes contrary to large-carcass specialists like griffon vultures46,48. This scenario lends a new twist to the probability of maintenance of the populations of medium-sized avian scavengers.
Alternatively, from a demographic point of view, it is much more appropriate to focus future conservation efforts on reducing the risks of non–natural mortality in the hostile landscapes surrounding the protected areas. In our study case, the areas near the Natural Park are frequently selected by individuals because of the higher availability of carrion resources linked to the existence of both numerous farms with intensive and semi–intensive livestock operations and the development of arid lands for irrigated crops. These areas offer new habitats for small and medium–sized birds and mammals, whose carcasses could be exploited by scavengers49. On the other hand, in the surrounding areas the causes of mortality are mainly associated with the ingestion of poisoned baits used by local hunters and shepherds to control carnivores27,50 and with accidents involving human-made structures such as wind farms51,52,53. Counteracting the use of poison may be feasible in the long-term but the total eradication of this practice is unlikely without great efforts in public education54,55. The reduction of the risk of mortality at wind farms may be more attainable because these accidents follow a spatially contagious distribution56. To date, however, mitigating measures have rarely been implemented57.
Finally, our results indicate that the viability of a rabbit consumer species is not independent of the potential competitor species: griffon vultures would currently consume about 26% of the available biomass of wild rabbit carcasses. Field data corroborate this: in fact, 60% of the rabbit carcasses monitored in the study area between 2004 and 2006 were consumed by this obligate scavenger species39 (authors unpublished). Our models predict that if the griffon vulture population doubles in abundance this species would consume 55% of the total rabbit biomass available vs. 45% consumed by Egyptian vultures. Within this scenario, the probability of Egyptian vulture population decline would be higher. The growth of the griffon vulture population in the study area and throughout the Iberian Peninsula has been exponential (from 3,249 breeding pairs in 1979 to 25,541 in 200858,28). Currently, due to lingering effects of the BSE crisis59 growth rates have slowed in some regions28 but a slow recovery was apparent in 2014. Sanitary regulations have recently changed allowing farmers to leave livestock carcasses to scavengers in the field24. It could be argued, however, that the Egyptian vultures also benefit from this new legislative framework as they feed on livestock remains as well, but this species depends more than other vultures on small and medium-sized vertebrates, probably due to qualitative nutrient requirements30,35. In fact, modeling outputs about population trends in relation to food shortages mediated by recent sanitary regulations (before 2011) suggested that the Egyptian vultures are far less sensitive than griffon vultures to changes in the supply of livestock carcasses35.
This study shows that PDP modeling procedures can be useful to determine the sensitivity of the demography of target species to changes in the behavior of individuals. Modeling strategies moving forward should aim to progress in these areas. For example, it is well–known that the degree of exploitation of a feeding place by Egyptian vultures is logically a function, though not linear, of the distance between the territory and the resource60,61). It is expected therefore, that the frequency of foraging trips outside the protected areas by the Egyptian vultures (as well as other long–ranging species) individually will depend on the spatial location of their territories. If the nests are located on the edge of natural protected areas then it is expected that the probabilities modeled here should vary (e.g. be higher). Moreover, it is also possible that there are intrinsic factors linked to each individual (sex, body size) that favor asymmetric competitive abilities and differential exploitation of space and food sources59,62. Finally, because individuals may present consistency in their behavior, asymmetries between them regarding the same behavioral traits are feasible63,64. The existence of personalities would add a new feature to the computation of survival probability of a bird performing foraging movements that involve certain variables of risks and rewards.
To conclude, although positive aspects in the recovery of threatened keystone species are widely recognized65, we suggest evaluating whether such recovery programs are cost–effective under changeable environmental conditions such as those supporting intensive human activity and with unstable balances in consumer populations. It has been shown that, in those systems based on a few keystone species supporting complex guilds of vertebrate consumers (whether carnivores or scavengers), the fate of the species in these assemblages may not be independent of the balance between their populations66,67,68,69,70,71. Moreover, the scenario created by the existence of protected areas within highly-humanized areas turns these into “ecological traps” where animals look for higher-quality resources but at the expense of higher mortality (see43 and references therein). Thus, this adds further constraints to the viability of populations of large body-sized vertebrates performing long-distance displacements.
Methods
Study area and monitoring of target species
The research was performed in the Bardenas Reales (Ebro Valley, northern Spain) (Fig. 5). This area encompasses around 50,000 ha of which around 80% have been protected since 1999 and 2000 as a Natural Park and Biosphere Reserve, respectively. This is a dry region (<300 mm/year of precipitation). It is dominated by large flat areas and small hills (280–659 m a.s.l.) with natural vegetation dominated by scrublands and small wooded patches. There are no permanent human settlements inside the Natural Park but there are large areas historically used for the traditional agricultural practices of cereal crops and grazing. In contrast, neighboring areas in the Ebro Valley are densely populated (more than 150,000 persons within 30 km of the area) and include large irrigated areas and many intensive livestock operations (see details in27).
Local populations of avian scavengers have been monitored annually since the early 1980s (see27). At that time, the density of Egyptian vultures was one of the highest known in the world with up to 50 breeding pairs (1 pair/10 km2). It has since declined by about 50% with only 23 breeding pairs active in 2013. During the breeding period, the Egyptian and the griffon vultures have been monitored following the well-established standard methodologies (see27,72). The annual productivity of Egyptian vultures showed variability (0.3–0.8 fledglings/occupied territory). While having been a frequent prospecting visitor, the first established breeding pair of griffon vultures was detected in 1990. Since then the population has sharply increased with 85 pairs recorded in 2013 (A. Urmeneta, unpublished data). Apart from the breeding population, there is a significant number of non-breeding birds (estimated to be of approximately similar size to the breeding fraction of the population) that forage in the same areas29,48,73 (authors unpublished). The annual productivity of griffon vultures has remained almost constant at around 0.4 fledglings/pair (see27, A. Urmeneta unpubl.).
Model built and assumptions
In the Population Dynamics P-system Models (PDP, see Supplementary Information) we integrated information on: a) reproduction, mortality and foraging behavior of the Egyptian vultures; b) wild rabbit carcass biomass availability, including the maximum carrying capacity of the study area; and c) carcass-sharing with direct trophic competitors (griffon vultures) (see detailed information in Supplementary Information). The model assumed that the diet of the focal species was primarily based on wild rabbits (>80%) until 1990. Subsequently and due to the demise of the wild rabbit in the Natural Park, the birds increased their foraging in humanized areas outside of the boundaries of the protected area. As a consequence, non-natural mortality increased mainly due to the ingestion of poisoning baits and accidents with infrastructures. This led to a decrease in breeding success (associated with the loss of the mate, poor-quality of trophic resources and increased foraging effort, see Supplementary Information).
The PDP model developed here is a computational modeling procedure structured according to five sequenced modules (see Fig. 6). In each module, we simulated each of the processes, with individuals evolving in parallel by means of the so-called “evolutionary rules” (see Supplementary Information for details). The first module executed the process of natural mortality and additional non-natural mortality linked to foraging movements of breeding Egyptian vultures perform into more highly humanized areas outside of the park. Birds that survive then begin the feeding process (module 2; see details in Supplementary Information). In the next module, are accounted the exits of the park for lack of food resources (module 3, how many times the individual leaves the park; see details in Supplementary Information). The foraging trips, including the potential exits of the park, are modeled daily for each month and are thus repeated 30 times. Taking the day as the unit time, modules 2 and 3 run 30 times each for the six months corresponding to the period spent by the vulture in its European breeding area. In the end, we get the number of times each animal leaves the park in search of food. This is the input for module 4, which addresses non-natural mortality due to the ingestion of poisoned baits. Once the month is completed, the model runs module 1 again and this loop is repeated six times, once for each month. At the end of the sixth month, the number of times the individual has gone in search of food on throughout the year is recorded. This parameter is the input for module 5, addressing the reproductive process. With the application of module 5 the execution of one year is complete. The loop should be repeated as many times as necessary to simulate years.
The model begins simulating an initial population in 1980 composed of 50 breeding pairs of Egyptian vultures and a similar number of non–breeding individuals, which includes birds between 1 and 5 years old. Immature birds became “breeding adults” in their eighth year of life72. New recruitments came from birds born during each new breeding season.
The individuals search for food daily in the protected area. Based on the data obtained from radio-tagged individuals studied in the 1980s74 (authors unpublished data) we consider that during this period around 20% of the foraging trips of the breeding individuals were outside the limits of protected area boundaries (i.e. in humanized areas). Before 1990, the use of poisoned baits outside the park was almost nonexistent and therefore we consider that there is initially a cost associated with foraging behavior outside the boundaries of the Natural Park and overall mortality is taken to be 2% and 10% per year for breeding and non-breeding birds, respectively. We also considered that before 1990 the yearly productivity was 0.4 fledglings/breeding female.
We then modeled the impact of the RHD. After the outbreak in 1990, Egyptian vultures increased foraging activity outside the limits of the Natural Park. Observations conducted with tagged individuals with plastic rings (up to 50% of the total population) showed that after the demise of wild rabbits the Egyptian vultures foraged in areas up to 30 km away from their nests (unpublished authors). We assume that this implies an associated cost that leads to a decline in breeding success by more than half (up to 0.2 chicks/breeding female see27). In addition, foraging outside the Natural Park had other costs associated with higher mortality risk due to the occasional use of poisoned baits by shepherds, mainly in nearby hunting areas after the arrival of the RHD27. Consequently, the mortality rates of adult breeding birds in this population were relatively high (17% annual)72. This risky scenario has remained unchanged as rabbit populations have not recovered and non–natural mortality remains important outside the limits of the protected areas.
To model the role of interspecific trophic competition we estimated the number of prospecting griffon vultures in the Natural Park on the basis of: a) the density of prospecting birds estimated by48 and b) the regional long–term population trends of the species in the region, which has shown invariable increments during the last three decades59 (see Figure S2 and also Supplementary Information). Before the RHD irruption in 1990, the griffon vulture relied almost exclusively on carcasses of livestock and only included the rabbit anecdotally75. However, due to the extensive closure of large feeding stations as a result of European sanitary regulations76,77, small prey items, including rabbits, increased significantly30,39. Griffon vultures dominate Egyptian vultures and other smaller scavengers at carcasses29,48. Therefore, our model assumed that if a griffon vulture finds a rabbit carcass it consumes the resource completely, impeding access by Egyptian vultures.
Finally, the daily biomass consumption of griffon and Egyptian vultures was calculated based on the methodology described by78 and followed by79 and80. For both species, two estimates were calculated: 1) one for territorial individuals that breed successfully and 2) the other for both territorial individuals who failed in breeding and non-territorial individuals. In the first case, it is assumed that during the chick-rearing period the consumption increases by up to 30% due to the increase in energetic requirements78. In the case of the griffon vultures, we assumed that only 25% of the total population breeds (50% of the griffons in the study area are not breeders and productivity per female is 0.25 chicks/year, authors unpublished).
Modeling future conservation policies
To determine how population viability may vary depending on different potential conservation polices and future management scenarios, we used a Box–Behnken design81. The Response Surface Methodology, to which the Box–Behnken design belongs, is a set of mathematical and statistical techniques used to model and analyze questions in which a variable of interest is influenced by others. The Box–Behnken designs make the estimation of the coefficients of first and second order more efficient than other designs. We specifically designed variations in two factors: food (rabbit carcasses) availability and mortality associated with daily foraging activity outside of the protected area. Food availability was measured as a percentage of the initial rabbit population existing in the study area (range: 0 to 100%). The mortality rates ranged from 2.4% to 25.5% when the vulture population remained stable and 2.5% to 100% when the vulture population doubled. The projections were simulated up to 35 years with 100 repetitions by year. Finally, we performed simulations in two different scenarios relative to the long-term trend of the griffon vulture population in the study area: stability (the population found in 2014 remains constant) and increase (the population doubles linearly in 35 years).
The model was executed using MeCoSim software (free software under license) developed by the Computation Group at the University of Sevilla (GNU GPL; http://www.p-lingua.org).
Additional Information
How to cite this article: Cortés-Avizanda, A. et al. Modeling the consequences of the demise and potential recovery of a keystone-species: wild rabbits and avian scavengers in Mediterranean landscapes. Sci. Rep. 5, 17033; doi: 10.1038/srep17033 (2015).
References
Power, M. E. et al. Challenges in the quest for keystones. BioScience 46, 609–620 (1996).
Simberloff, D. Flagships, umbrellas and keystones: Is single-species management passé in the landscape era? Biol. Conserv. 83, 247–257 (1998).
Libralato, S., Christensenc, V. & Paulyc, D. A method for identifying keystone species in food web models. Ecol. Model. 195, 153–171 (2006).
Begon, M., Townsend, C. R. & Harper, J. L. Ecology: from Individuals to Ecosystems. (Blackwell Publishing, Malden, MA, 2006).
Gibbs, J. P., Hunter, Jr. M. L. & Sterling, E. J. Problem-solving in Conservation Biology and Wildlife Management, 2nd edition. (Blackwell Science: Malden, MA, 2008).
Hansen, D. M. On the use of taxon substitutes in rewilding projects on islands. In: Islands and Evolution. (eds Pérez-Mellado, V. & Ramon, C. ) 111–146 (Institut Menorquí d’Estudis, Menorca 2010).
Kaufman, M. J. et al. Landscape heterogeneity shapes predation in a newly restored predator–prey system. Ecol. Lett. 10, 690–700 (2007).
Delibes-Mateos, M., Delibes, M., Ferreras, P. & Villafuerte, R. Key role of European Rabbits in the conservation of the Western Mediterranean Basin hotspot. Conserv. Biol. 22, 1106–1117 (2008).
Delibes, M. & Hiraldo, F. The rabbit as prey in the Iberian Mediterranean ecosystem in Proceedings of the I World lagomorph conference. (eds Myers, K. & MacInnes, C. D. ) 614–622 (University of Guelph, Guelph, Ontario, Canada, 1981).
Ferrer, M. & Negro, J. J. The near extinction of two large European predators: super specialists pay a price. Conserv. Biol. 18, 344–349 (2004).
Villafuerte, R., Calvete, C. Blanco, J. C. & Lucientes, J. Incidence of viral hemorrhagic disease in wild rabbit populations in Spain. Mammalia 59, 651–659 (1995).
Virgós, E., Cabezas-Díaz, S. & Lozano, J. Is the wild rabbit (Oryctolagus cuniculus) a threatened species in Spain? Sociological constraints in the conservation of species. Biodivers. Conserv. 16, 3489–3504 (2007).
Martínez, J. A. & Zuberogoitia, I. The response of the Eagle Owl (Bubo bubo) to an outbreak of the rabbit haemorrhagic disease. J. Ornithol. 142, 204–211 (2001).
Moreno-Rueda, G., Pizarro, M., Ontiveros, D. & Pleguezuelos, J. M. The coexistence of the eagles Aquila chrysaetos and Hieraaetus fasciatus increases with low human population density, intermediate temperature and high. Ann. Zool. Fenn. 46, 283–290 (2009).
Moleón, M. et al. Predator–prey relationships in a Mediterranean vertebrate system: Bonelli’s eagles, rabbits and partridges. Oecologia 168, 679–689 (2012).
Moleón, M. et al. Large scale spatiotemporal shifts in the diet of a predator mediated by an emerging infectious disease of its main prey. J. Biogeogr. 36, 1502–1515 (2009).
Ferreras, P., Travaini, A., Zapata, S. C. & Delibes, M. Short-term responses of mammalian carnivores to a sudden collapse of rabbits in Mediterranean Spain. Basic Appl. Ecol. 12, 116–124 (2011).
Ferreras, P., Aldama, J. J., Beltr, J. F. & Delibes, M. Rates and causes of mortality in a fragmented population of Iberian lynx Felis pardina Temminck, 1824. Biol. Conserv. 61, 197–202 (1992).
Villafuerte, R., Viñuela, J. & Blanco, J. C. Extensive predator persecution cased by population crash in a game species: the case of red kites and rabbit in Spain. Biol. Conserv. 84, 181–188 (1998).
Márquez, C., Vargas, J. M., Villafuerte, R. & Fa, J. E. Understanding the propensity of wild predators to illegal poison baiting. Anim. Conserv. 16, 118–129 (2013).
Cabezas, S. & Moreno, S. An experimental study of translocation success and habitat improvement in wild rabbits. Anim. Conserv. 10, 340–348 (2007).
Simón, M. A. et al. Reverse of the decline of the endangered Iberian Lynx. Conserv. Biol. 26, 731–736 (2012).
Moreno, S., Villafuerte, R., Cabezas, S. & Lombardi, L. Wild rabbit restocking for predator conservation in Spain. Biol. Conserv. 118, 183–193 (2004).
Margalida, A. Baits, budget cuts: A deadly mix. Science 338, 192 (2012).
Ferreras, P., Gaona, P. Palomares, F. & Delibes, M. Restore habitat or reduce mortality? Implications from a population viability analysis of the Iberian lynx. Anim. Conserv. 4, 265–274 (2001).
Tylianakis, J. M., Didham, R. K., Bascompte, J. & Wardle, D. A. Global change and species interactions in terrestrial ecosystems. Ecol. Lett. 11, 1351–1363 (2008).
Cortés-Avizanda, A., Ceballos, O. & Donázar, J. A. Long-term trends in population size and breeding success in the Egyptian vulture (Neophron percnopterus) in Northern Spain. J. Raptor. Res. 43, 43–49 (2009).
Del Moral, J. C. (Ed.). El buitre leonado en España. Población reproductora: método de censo. (SEO/BirdLife. Madrid-Spain 2009).
Cortés-Avizanda, A., Jovani, R., Carrete, M. & Donázar, J. A. Resource unpredictability promotes species diversity and coexistence in an avian scavenger guild: a field experiment. Ecology 93, 2570–2579 (2012).
Donázar, J. A., Cortés-Avizanda, A. & Carrete, M. Dietary shifts in two vultures after the demise of supplementary feeding stations: consequences of the EU sanitary legislation. European J. Wildl. Res. 56, 613–621 (2010).
Colomer, M. A., Margalida, A. & Pérez-Jiménez, M. Population dynamic P system (PDP) models: a standardized protocol for describing and applying novel bio-inspired computing tools. PLoS ONE 8, e60698 (2013).
Păun, G. Computing with membranes. J. Comput. Syst. Sci. 61, 108–143 (1998).
Colomer, M. A., Margalida, A., Sanuy, D. & Pérez-Jiménez, M. J. A bio-inspired computing model as a new tool for modeling ecosystems: the avian scavengers as a case study. Ecol. Model. 222, 33–47 (2011).
Colomer, M. A., Margalida, A., Valencia, L. & Palau, A. Application of a computational model for complex fluvial ecosystems: The population dynamics of zebra mussel (Dreissena polymorpha) as a case study. Ecol. Compl. 20, 116–126 (2014).
Margalida, A. & Colomer, M. A. Modeling the effects of sanitary policies on European vulture conservation. Sci. Rep. 2, 753 (2012).
Kane, A., Jackson, A. L., Monadjem, A., Colomer, M. A. & Margalida, A. Carrion ecology modelling for vulture conservation: are vulture restaurants needed to sustain the densest breeding population of the African white-backed vulture? Anim. Conserv. 18, 279–286 (2014).
Fernández, M., Oria, J., Sánchez, R., González, L. M. & Margalida, A. Space use of adult Spanish Imperial Eagles (Aquila adalberti). Acta Ornithol. 44, 17–26 (2009).
Pérez-Garcia, J. M. et al. Interannual home range variation, territoriality and overlap in breeding Bonelli’s eagles (Aquila fasciata) tracked by GPS satellite telemetry. J. Ornith. 154, 63–71 (2013).
Sebastián-González, E. et al. Interactive effects of obligate scavengers and scavenger community richness on lagomorph carcass consumption patterns. Ibis 155, 881–885 (2013).
Moreno, S. et al. Long-term decline of the European wild rabbit (Oryctolagus cuniculus) in south-western Spain. Wildl. Res. 34, 652–658 (2007).
Abrantes, J. et al. New variant of rabbit hemorrhagic disease virus, Portugal, 2012-2013. Emerg. Infect. Dis. 19, 1900–1902 (2013).
Delibes-Mateos, M., Ferreira, C., Carro, F., Escudero, M. A. & Gortázar, C. Ecosystem effects of variant rabbit hemorrhagic disease virus, Iberian Peninsula. Emerg. Infect. Dis. 20, 2166–2168 (2014).
Navarro, L. M. & Pereira, H. M. Rewilding Abandoned Landscapes in Europe. Ecosystems 15, 900–912 (2012).
Pereira, H. M. & Navarro, L. (ed.) Rewilding European landscapes. (Springer. London 2015).
Blázquez-Alvarez, M. & Sánchez-Zapata, J. A. The role of wild ungulates as a resource for the community of vertebrate scavengers, in: Vultures, feeding stations and sanitary legislation: A conflict and its consequences from the perspective of conservation biology. Donázar, J. A., Margalida, A. & Campión, D. (eds) 308–327 (Munibe 29 Suppl., Sociedad de Ciencias Aranzadi, San Sebastián-Spain 2009).
Cortés-Avizanda, A., Donázar, J. A. & Pereira, H. M. Top scavengers in a wilder Europe, in: Rewilding European landscapes (eds Pereira H. M. & Navarro L. N. ). 85–106 (Springer. London 2015).
Delibes-Mateos, M., Redpath, S. E., Angulo, E., Ferreras, P. & Villafuerte, R. Rabbits as a keystone species in southern Europe. Biol. Conserv. 137, 149–156 (2007).
Cortés-Avizanda, A., Jovani, R., Donázar, J. A. & Grimm, V. Birds sky networks: How do avian scavengers search for carrion resource. Ecology 95, 1799–1808 (2014).
Sánchez-Zapata, J. A. et al. Breeding waterbirds in relation to artificial pond attributes: implications for the design of irrigation facilities. Biodiv. Conserv. 14, 1627–1639 (2005).
Hernández, F. & Margalida, A. Poison-related mortality effects in the endangered Egyptian Vulture (Neophron percnopterus) population in Spain: conservation measures. Eur. J. Wildl. Res. 55, 415–423 (2009).
Lehman, R. N., Kennedy, P. L. & Savidge, J. A. The state of the art in raptor electrocution research: a global review. Biol. Conserv. 136, 159–174 (2007).
Carrete, M., Sánchez-Zapata, J. A., Benítez, J. R., Lobón, M. & Donázar, J. A. Large scale risk-assessment of wind-farms on population viability of a globally endangered long-lived raptor. Biol. Conserv. 142, 2954–2961 (2009).
Rioux, S., Savard, J.-P. L. & Gerick, A. A. Avian mortalities due to transmission line collisions: a review of current estimates and field methods with an emphasis on applications to the Canadian electric network. Avian Conserv. Ecol. 8, 7 (2013).
Whitfield, D. P., McLeod, D. R. A., Watson, J., Fielding, A. H. & Haworth, P. F. The association of grouse moor in Scotland with the illegal use of poisons to control predators. Biol. Conserv. 114, 157–163 (2003).
Mineau, P., Lyon, L. & McMillin, S. Impacts of Carbofuran on Birds in Canada and the United States in Carbofuran and Wildlife Poisoning: Global Perspectives and Forensic Approaches (ed. Richards, N. ) (John Wiley & Sons, Ltd, Chichester, UK. 2011).
Carrete, M. et al. The precautionary principle and wind-farm planning: data scarcity does not imply absence of effects. Biol. Conserv. 143, 1829–1830 (2010).
Márquez, C., Vargas, J. M., Villafuerte, R. & Fa, J. E. Risk mapping of illegal poisoning of avian and mammalian predators. J. Wildl. Manag. 77, 75 (2013).
Parra, J. & Tellería, J. L. The increase in the Spanish population of Griffon vulture Gyps fulvus during 1989–1999: effects of food and nest site availability. Bird Conser. Int. 14, 33–41 (2004).
Donázar, J. A., Margalida, A. & Campión, D. (ed). Vultures, feeding stations and sanitary legislation: a conflict and its consequences from the perspective of conservation biology. Munibe 29 Suppl. (Sociedad de Ciencias Aranzadi, San Sebastian-Spain. ISSN 1698–3807 (2009)).
García-Heras, S., Cortés-Avizanda, A. & Donázar, J. A. Who are we feeding? Asymmetric individual use of surplus food resources in an insular population of the endangered Egyptian vulture Neophron percnopterus. PLoS ONE 8, e80523 (2013).
Carrete, M., Donázar, J. A. & Margalida, A. Density-dependent productivity depression in Pyrenean bearded vultures: implications for conservation. Ecol. Appl. 16, 1674–1682 (2006).
López-Bao, J. V., Rodríguez, A. & Palomares, F. Competitive asymmetries in the use of supplementary food by the endangered Iberian Lynx (Lynx pardinus). PLoS ONE 4, e7610 (2009).
McDougall, P., Réale, D., Sol, D. & Reader, S. Wildlife conservation and animal temperament: causes and consequences of evolutionary change for captive, reintroduced and wild populations. Anim. Conserv. 9, 39–48 (2006).
Réale, D., Reader, S. M., Sol, D., McDougall, P. T. & Dingemanse, N. J. Integrating 750 animal temperament within ecology and evolution. Biol. Rev. 82, 291–318 (2007).
MacDonald, D. W. & Willis, K. J. (ed.). Key topics in conservation biology 2. (John Wiley & Sons. Wiley-Blackwell, Oxford, UK. 2013).
Jedrzejewska, B. & Jedrzejewski, W. Predation in vertebrate communities. The Białowieza Primeval Forest as a case study. (Springer-Verlag. Berlin. 1998).
Sergio, F. et al. Preservation of wide-ranging top predators by site-protection: Black and Red kites in Doñana National Park. Biol. Conserv. 125, 11–21 (2005).
Ritchie, E. G. & Johnson, C. N. Predator interactions, mesopredator release and biodiversity conservation. Ecol. Lett. 12, 982–998 (2009).
Balme, G. A., Slotow, R. & Hunter, L. T. B. Edge effects and the impact of non-protected areas in carnivore conservation: leopards in the Phinda–Mkhuze Complex, South Africa. Anim. Conserv. 13, 315–323 (2010).
Moleón, M., Sánchez-Zapata, J. A., Selva, N., Donázar, J. A. & Owen-Smith, N. Inter-specific interactions linking predation and scavenging in terrestrial vertebrate assemblages. Biol. Rev. 89, 1042–1054 (2014).
Yackulic, C. B. et al. The roles of competition and habitat in the dynamics of populations and species distributions. Ecology 95, 265–279 (2014).
Grande, J. M. et al. Survival in a long-lived territorial migrant: Effects of life-history traits and ecological conditions in wintering and breeding areas. Oikos 118, 580–590 (2009).
Donázar, J. A., Ceballos, O. & Tella, J. L. Communal roost of Egyptian vultures (Neophron percnopterus): dynamics and implications for the species conservation in: Biology and Conservation of Mediterranean Raptors (ed. Muntaner, J. & Mayol, J. ) 189–202, (SEO/BirdLife, Monography 4. Madrid-Spain 1996).
Donázar, J. A. & Ceballos, O. Alimentación y tasas reproductoras del Alimoche (Neophron percnopterus) en Navarra. Ardeola 35, 3–14 (1988).
Donázar, J. A. Los buitres ibéricos. Biología y conservación. (ed. Reyero J. M. ). (Madrid- Spain 1993).
Donázar, J. A., Margalida, A., Carrete, M. & Sánchez-Zapata, J. A. Too sanitary for vultures. Science 326, 664 (2009).
Margalida, A., Donázar, J. A., Carrete, M. & Sánchez‐Zapata, J. A. Sanitary versus environmental policies: fitting together two pieces of the puzzle of European vulture conservation J. Appl. Ecol. 47, 931–935 (2010).
Houston, D. C. The adaptations of scavengers. in Serengeti: dynamics of an ecosystem. (eds Sinclair, A. R. E. & Griffiths, M. N. ). 236–286. (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, Illinois, USA. 1979).
Hiraldo, F. Diet of the Black Vulture (Aegypius monachus) in the Iberian Peninsula. Doñana Acta Vert. 3, 19–31 (1976).
Hiraldo, F. Breeding biology of the Cinereous vulture in Vulture biology and management. (ed. Wilbur, S. R. & Jackson, J. A. )197–213, (University of California Press, Berkeley 1983).
Box, G. E. P. & Behnken, D. W. Some new three level design for the study of quantitative variables. Technometrics 2, 455–475 (1960).
Acknowledgements
We gratefully acknowledge the staff of Bardenas Reales Natural Park, specially to Alejandro Urmeneta, for logistical support at field work and the Natural Computing Group at the University of Seville for their help with the design of the simulator. Catarina C. Ferreira and two anonymous referees provided helpful and constructive comments on earlier draft. This study was funded by the Project CGL2012-40013-C02-01. ACA was supported by a post-doctoral grant from the Fundação para a Ciência e a Tecnologia (FCT) (SFRH/BPD/91609/2012). A.M. was supported by a “Ramón y Cajal” research contract by Ministry of Economy and Competitiveness (RYC-2012-11867). M. de la Riva helped with map creation.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
A.C.A. and J.A.D. conceived the idea. A.C.A., J.A.D. and O.C. collected the data. A.M. and M.A.C. performed the modeling. All the authors discussed the results, commented and contributed to write the manuscript.
Ethics declarations
Competing interests
The authors declare no competing financial interests.
Electronic supplementary material
Rights and permissions
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons license, unless indicated otherwise in the credit line; if the material is not included under the Creative Commons license, users will need to obtain permission from the license holder to reproduce the material. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
About this article
Cite this article
Cortés-Avizanda, A., Colomer, M., Margalida, A. et al. Modeling the consequences of the demise and potential recovery of a keystone-species: wild rabbits and avian scavengers in Mediterranean landscapes. Sci Rep 5, 17033 (2015). https://doi.org/10.1038/srep17033
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/srep17033
This article is cited by
-
Forage offering and seasonal intake comparisons to evaluate European rabbit threat in Nothofagus forests of southern Patagonia
Ecological Processes (2022)
-
Application of protein nutrition in natural ecosystem management for European rabbit (Oryctolagus cuniculus) conservation
Biodiversity and Conservation (2022)
-
Social actors’ perceptions of wildlife: Insights for the conservation of species in Mediterranean protected areas
Ambio (2022)
-
Distribution of avian scavengers inside and outside of protected areas: contrasting patterns between two areas of Spain and South Africa
Biodiversity and Conservation (2020)
-
Translocation of keystone species may not mean translocation of keystone effect
European Journal of Wildlife Research (2019)
Comments
By submitting a comment you agree to abide by our Terms and Community Guidelines. If you find something abusive or that does not comply with our terms or guidelines please flag it as inappropriate.