The publication policy of Commentaries is long established. The Commentary section, like the Book Reviews and Correspondence sections, is intended to convey original and stimulating opinions, both solicited and unsolicited, from outside contributors. Publication does not imply endorsement by Nature of the authors' views. In contrast to Articles, Letters and Brief Communications, not all Commentaries are refereed, but it is Nature's policy to seek advice especially where we believe there is a risk of readers being misled. On the few occasions when, despite that policy, falsehoods or significant misrepresentations have been published, rebuttals or corrections have been published as soon as possible.